As To Her Illness, Nothing of Course: Psychosomatic Illness in Austens Emma         flat out the inattentive lector nonices a certain satirical and comedic element the treatment of various maladyes in Emma, especi tot bothyy as depicted through the characterization of Mr. Woodho enjoyment. just forthwith upon skinnyr examination, the cargonful contri onlyor realizes that humanityy characters, til now and especially Mr. Woodhouse, confront signs of sickishness self-inflicted, unhealthiness as a product of a neurotic fix, or even hypochondriasis.         Mr. Woodhouse provides the easiest and most extreme example of hypochondria in the entire novel. Indeed, we match very primaeval, non alto calculateher that his contain could bear goose egg rich, precisely that he would gladly focus others on wellness familiarly: What was unwhole about to him, he hold up acrossed as unfit for everybody (14). In itself this does non reckon odd, completely the reader moldiness necessarily find it comedic that Mr. Woodhouse regards a spousals cake with great distress, consults an apothecary about it, and even soberly tried to dissuade [the partygoers] from having conjugal union cake at all, and when that acetify out vain, as earnestly tried to pr p naughtilyow slip anybodys school in it(14-15). These passages set the stage for manifest satirical characterization, as no(prenominal) entirely the stodgiest and caperable obsolete man would honestly veto cake at a wedding. just the narrator gives the cake eaters a last triumphant laugh: There was a obscure rumour in Highbury of all the little Perrys world verifyn with a slice of Mr. Westons wedding cake in their hands; but Mr. Woodhouse would never bust everywhere it(15).         Aside from the early introduction, Woodhouse is satirized even nonwithstanding in his ramblings oer Isabella and the health of her children, and in his discussions with her regarding their opposin! g apothecaries. We take aim here of his strange penchant for gruel and his hunch over and high friendship for a quicken, Mr. Perry, who is bilious, and has not time to take cargon of himself(84). Who would take sternly a bilious physician? And, similar to the scene in which Woodhouse admonishes wedding cake, he is afterwards depicted satirically in his opposition, for reasons of health, over over against a ball, and his eventual dissuasion by dog Churchills persistence. In all of these scenes Mr. Woodhouse is made to whole tone like nothing more than a doting, hypochondriacal old gentleman, to be honour but hardly taken seriously.         The offset printing font in which a specific infirmity bears upon the plot, however, regards Harriet and her kin with Mr. Elton. Specifically, Harriet mustiness miss the Christmas even dinner at Randalls, because she had done for(p) fireside so much indisposed with a shivery(85). turn we ca-ca no cultivate reason to regard Harriets fever and bad sore throat with suspicion, we do motility why Mr. Perry, as so often is the case, is notwithstanding talked of, but never appears on the scene (85). And, precondition the general item of the events surrounding Harriets illness, the reader is naturally curious. Is it tall(a) that a materialisation, sickening, distaff outsider to Highbury aristocracy might not develop some disturbedness as a run of excitement in the first chip of her first run across with a potential wooer? Are not the stakes likewise high for young Harriet, in that she has so much equitation on Mr. Eltons ( maintain) courtship, that she might naturally give way sick? sure as shooting Harriets natural temperament raises that the illness is neurotic, in that we later find her extremely upset in the slightest situations (e.g. her meeting with Mr. Martin and his sister) and see her give way to extreme corporal reactions, as when she faints later on a confr ontation with gypsies.         Jane Fa! irfaxs illness is not mingled to Harriets, except that we flummox more direct yard indicating that it is every faked or psychosomatic entirely. Much like Harriet, Janes illness arises within the context of use of a situation of stress. She is to plough governess for the Smallridges, which is a major difference in station from the pickaxe: to marry Frank Churchill. Jane app arntly suffers from severe headaches, and a nervous fever, as reported by Mr. Perry himself. On the other hand, her health take c ared for the moment completely derangedappetite quite asleep(p) which indicates both in (figurative) language and content that the illness may be psychosomatic (307). Janes illness results, of play, in the slow up of her engagement to the Smallridges. Necessary also to the context is that Jane holds resentment toward Emma, who is duty on her, for past grievances. While Emma calls on her, Jane sends all of her invitations and sympathy back. This is even treated somew hat humorously in cast Batess answer to Emmas query: Indeed the rectitude was, that pitiable Jane could not bear to see anybodyanybody at allMrs. Elton, indeed, could not be deniedand Mrs. Cole had made such a blotand Mrs. Perry had said so muchbut, except them, Jane would in verity see nobody(308) The insistence that Jane will see nobody, get with the accounts of her seeing so many, puts a satirical light on Janes deliberate snubbing of Emma. Still, Jane must exhibit some symptoms, as Miss Bates and even Mr. Perry are party to Janes actions. Emma and the reader realize fully that Jane is probably not truly ill when we learn that she had been seen wandering about the meadows on the same afternoon Emma had called (309). We pick up nothing else of Janes illness after we learnin the next chapterthat Frank has returned and announced his engagement with Jane, which tho evidences the possibility of the illness being wholly dependent upon her situation, and thus psychosomati c.         If we were to consider any ! illness suffered in Emma, Mrs. Churchills would appear the most valid, in that she dies in the bunk of things. but we must take careful note that she did not die from her sibylline sickness: A sudden seizure of a different nature from anything foreboded by her general state had carried her off after a short struggle (306). Is it entirely out of butt to consider that she seized after hearing the news of Franks engagement to Jane, which would most likely have been told to her directly in the lead he left again to announce it to Highbury? sure as shooting we have indication that Mrs. Churchill has done her best to hold in the attentions of Frank, including care him from his father, so his announcement of engagement would naturally be a sedate blow to her.         crimson outside of her death (which change magnitude her popularity immensely), we chouse Mrs. Churchill uses illness as a manipulative tool, even if the event [of her death] acquitted her of all the fancifulness, and all the selfishness of imaginary complaints(306). Frank knows that her illnesses are psychosomatic: Her knew her illnesses; they never occurred but for his own lash-up(204). And the context gives us equal certainty, as Frank has been kept from Highbury only if by Mrs. Churchills efforts, so it is natural that she would take place to do so. The move to Richmondcloser to Highbury and to Frankas an alleged alleviation of her illnesses is yet another scheme to use her physical state as a tool to keep him close.         Of course, we have also two minor instances of illness which seem to be serious and real. The first is the illness of the poor family whom Harriet and Emma go to figure early (in Chapters 9 and 10 of Volume 1). The state of the family is serious, and Emma and Harriet chatter them out of apparent companionable duty, and reflect seriously on the familys state of being as compared with their own. Further, we hear cente r(prenominal) through the novel that Mrs. Weston has ! fallen ill. Interestingly, Mr. Weston, in his excitement to get word friends and hold the center of attention, rebukes Mrs. Weston, and says, As to her illness, all nothing of course(238). This could be an indication of presumed psychosomatic or hypochondriac nature, but it could equally represent a fault in Mr. Weston. And we are given no clear indication later, when Mrs. Weston is described as looking so ill, and had an air of so much perturbation, again skewing the line between real sickness and mere noetic irritability (311).         That illness in Emma is often, if not entirely, psychosomatic or hypochondriacal, is clearly evident. Characters consistently use illness as a manipulative tool, either to receive attention (as with Mr. Woodhouse and Mrs. Churchill), or to immobilize attention (as with Harriet and Jane). Certainly some of this is meant as deliberate satire, as the ramblings of Mr. Woodhouse and the almost comedic representation of Janes il lness by Mrs. Bates indicate. even Mrs. Churchills use of illness to manipulate Frank takes on a satirical air.         Though some major events turn on illness, as with Harriets not attending the Christmas Eve party, it could hardly be said that illness is central to novel. We could not compare it, for example, to the centrality of parties or of familial visits or marital propositions. But we can note this: illness as something psychosomatic and not truly pathological is an accepted practice by citizens of Highbury. That the boilers pillow slip acceptance of this practice is a product merely of the historical context is questionable clearly Austen intends a certain hearty satire in her characterization of Mr. Woodhouse, Mrs. Churchill, and even in Janes snubbing of Emma. As a result, the reader may naturally close up that the consistent manipulative use of illness by characters is meant to immortalise a certain lack of seriousness or satirical presentati on of social life among the aristocracy at Highbury. ! A poor family suffers the only real illness end-to-end the novel, the doctor is suspiciously not present, and every other illness suffered is given a possible mental cause or direct evidence that it is psychosomatic. So a close schooling of the evidence suggests that we are to take such use of illnesses as we are to take Mr. Woodhouse, with a grain of salt.         If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: BestEssayCheap.com
If you want to get a full essay, visit our page: cheap essay
No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.